UPDATE: On February 9, 2022 our region collectively shrugged as yet another young pedestrian was killed by a car driven unchecked on what has become an urban speedway.
Police say a 27-year-old female pedestrian was walking across Bailey Avenue near Broadway when she was hit by a white SUV.
— WGRZ (@WGRZ) February 9, 2022
We have to continue writing about this issue, and shouting about it from the rooftops because for some reason, the outrage over these preventable deaths is missing from our region. We find ways to blame these incidents on the pedestrians and cyclists when it’s cars that do the killing.
Our insatiable need for speed, and our ingrained mantra of “20-minute city” excuses everyone speeding whenever they can find an opening.
Look at the lack of shoveling in intersections, at bus stops and bus shelters city-wide. We’ve all combined efforts to declare that if you don’t own a car, or chose to walk/ride somewhere instead of driving, then you had your death coming.
It’s unacceptable, and City Hall has been let off the hook for too long, especially when it comes to Bailey Avenue and the lack of priority it’s been given, despite all the crashes on it each year. The woman killed Wednesday night happened to be crossing Bailey near Broadway, which is controlled by the NYS DOT. They, too, continue to ignore the plight of cyclists and pedestrians, struck at rates of over 150 per year, and have not implemented any new infrastructure to slow cars and give pedestrians and cyclists refuge either.
We say “crashes” not “accidents.” It’s no accident when sidewalk aren’t cleared and roads aren’t even painted to give pedestrians any sort of refuge or indication thereof. This young woman’s death is as much the fault of the driver as it is the city and state’s for ignoring Bailey Ave for so long.
Here’s last year’s original article citing the excuses for dis-investing in one of Buffalo’s major corridors:
It’s No Accident: Man Killed While Cycling on Bailey Avenue is One of 160 Struck in the Last Five Years
Residents and business owners have been asking Mayor Brown and the City of Buffalo Department of Public Works for years to implement traffic calming measures to no avail.
Early Sunday, a man was struck and killed by the driver of a motor vehicle at the 1700 block of Bailey Avenue. Since 2014, 120 pedestrians and 41 bicyclists have been hit by motor vehicles on Bailey Avenue, with three of these crashes resulting in fatalities (view our crash map).
The City of Buffalo’s Department of Public Works has agreed to long-term improvements on Bailey Avenue; however, these will take years to implement. In the interim, as requested by community members and business owners, temporary improvements should be immediately implemented to prevent future injuries and deaths of those traveling the corridor and further property damage and deleterious economic impacts for Bailey Avenue businesses.
“The Department of Public Works tells us they don’t have money. They find money for all kinds of projects all over town but not the east side. The community has asked for stripes on Bailey for years, it’s busy on Bailey, there are new schools and businesses going in. We need infrastructure for safety. How many “accidents” have there been?” said George Johnson, President of Buffalo United Front, Co-Founder of the East Side Bike Club, and member of the Bicycle Pedestrian Advisory Board. “At some point, if you’re in charge, you need to look yourself in the mirror, and ask, what are you doing to make things safer for people. The way it looks now, it looks like you don’t care about the people on the east side. I bring recommendations to the Bike-Ped board, from my community for safety. The city spends all this money on law enforcement, that is money you can use to build things up so you won’t need law enforcement.”
“We are urging Mayor Brown, the Common Council, and the Department of Public Works to make immediate temporary traffic calming improvements, including crosswalks, a centerline, and temporary bike lanes, on Bailey Avenue,” said Justin Booth, executive director of GObike Buffalo. “The city’s continued negligence towards this corridor has contributed to three deaths in the past five years. The Bailey Avenue corridor, which is the most dangerous street in the City of Buffalo and has been historically disinvested in for more than half a century, should be the city’s top priority.”
Traffic violence involving pedestrians and bicyclists is on the rise around the nation and has resulted in millions of injuries and more than 7,000 pedestrian and bicyclists deaths. The Buffalo-Niagara region is a hot-bed for bicycle and pedestrian injuries and fatalities–from 2008 to 2018, 44 people were killed by vehicles while walking or biking in the City of Buffalo. A disproportionate number of those injured and killed are people of color.
Recent History of Bailey Avenue Infrastructure Requests
In 2018, the Better on Bailey: Infrastructure Plan was completed, developed for University District Community Development Association University District Council Member Rasheed N.C. Wyatt and the Greater Buffalo Niagara Regional Transportation Council with funding through the Buffalo Main Streets Initiative. The report states:
“The lack of crosswalks and other street markings is the most glaring issue faced by Bailey Avenue. Markings need to be painted as soon as possible to make the streetscape safer for people crossing, driving, parking, walking, and biking along Bailey. Without these improvements, Bailey Avenue is a 50-foot wide asphalt no-man’s-zone, preventing many types of retail businesses from being as successful as they can be.”
In November of 2019, in response to a letter from a business on Bailey Avenue, the City of Buffalo’s bicycle and pedestrian advisory board asked the Mayor and Common Council to immediately implement necessary improvements, including adding a center driving line and painting crosswalks. The business requested these improvements after a vehicle crashed into the storefront causing significant damage; the third such occasion in as many years.
The City of Buffalo initiated a feasibility study for Bailey Avenue. In January 2020, it hosted a public town hall meeting, encouraging the public to discuss and learn more about future improvement projects along the University District’s portion of Bailey Avenue.
To date, they have not made any temporary improvements.
The Importance of Infrastructure
Proper infrastructure provides safer conditions for all users. In the absence of adequate facilities, people walking and biking are more likely “break the rules” to navigate unsafe and inadequate conditions. When streets are designed only for those who can afford automobiles in mind, this happens with disturbing and deadly regularity.
The presence of separate and protected bike lanes are the most reliable indicator of lower fatality and injury rates for all users. In cities where cycle tracks were most abundant on a citywide basis, fatal crash rates dropped by 44 percent compared to the average city, and injury rates halved. The evidence suggests that protected cycle tracks decrease traffic safety risks for drivers, too. Though data is limited, we’ve seen this in our city, as well– Delaware Avenue complete streets stats.
Additionally, the COVID-19 health crisis has resulted in more than a 50 percent reduction in traffic volumes. With less motor vehicle traffic, there has been a glut of excessive speeding on our roadways. Many cities have allocated space on streets, now unused by motor vehicles, to make them safer for bicyclists and pedestrians, using this time to advance quick build projects to test safety enhancements on streets.
While working to implement longer-term equitable investment in street safety, the city should take immediate action to improve conditions in neighborhoods that have faced systemic disinvestment to enhance the quality of life for road users most vulnerable to traffic violence and injury. Mayor Brown should immediately fund the painting of crosswalks, stripe bicycle lanes, and curb bump-outs. Additionally, the city should work proactively with neighbors and local organizations on quick- build pop-up projects to create safe, complete streets in our city.
About the East Side Bike Club. The East Side Bike Club, an off-shoot of the Buffalo United Front, was started in 2016 with the aim of providing a safe riding experience for residents of the East Side. In 2017, the East Side Bike Club started its “Earn a Bike Clinic” on Bailey Avenue for area residents where they could acquire a bike by working and learning at the clinic. To date, the ESBC has around 75 members and has facilitated more than 150 people in earning a bike.
About GObike Buffalo. GObike Buffalo is sponsored by Independent Health. We are working to build a thriving, dynamic and connected Buffalo Niagara region by promoting biking, alternative transportation options, and improved streetscapes to create positive impacts on health, our environment, our streets, and the overall quality of life for all residents. For more information, visit us at gobikebuffalo.org.